While mobile wallets, digital banking, and electronic payment systems are growing, especially in urban centers, cash has proven resilient across much of the continent, serving as a mainstay for millions of people. But why does cash remain so essential in Africa’s economy, and what are the implications of this reliance?
Cash reliance across Africa is influenced by limited digital infrastructure, socio-economic factors, and consumer comfort. In South Africa, for instance, over 60% of transactions are cash-based, with a majority of low-income consumers finding it a trusted and practical option. Cash preference remains high, especially for essential expenses like transport, school fees, and utilities.
Why Cash Remains Essential in Africa
Cash plays a unique role in Africa's financial ecosystem due to a combination of socio-economic factors, infrastructure limitations, and cultural preferences. In South Africa, for example, cash still accounts for over 50% of all transactions by value, particularly among lower-income consumers. In other countries across the continent, this percentage is even higher, with cash often preferred for day-to-day transactions.
A recent study by SBV Services highlighted that about 64% of South Africans still prefer cash, citing reasons such as ease of use, control, and trust in physical currency. For many, cash is more than just a payment method; it’s a way of managing finances in a direct and tangible way. With limited access to formal banking infrastructure in rural and remote areas, cash often becomes a default option by necessity.
The Economic Costs of Cash Reliance
While cash is trusted and accessible, reliance on it comes with its own set of economic costs. A study by Genesis Analytics and MasterCard estimated that South African consumers pay about R23 billion annually in direct and indirect costs associated with cash use, including travel expenses to access ATMs, time spent in lines, and the risk of theft.
Additionally, those who keep large amounts of cash miss out on potential interest earnings and may incur transaction fees when accessing banking services.
For low-income individuals, these costs are disproportionately high, making cash both a necessity and a burden. This dynamic creates a paradox: cash is often the easiest option for immediate transactions, yet it incurs higher cumulative costs over time.
Cash Preference vs. Digital Adoption
Despite the push for digital financial services, adoption remains uneven. Even as mobile banking and digital wallets have made impressive gains, particularly in urban centers, a large segment of the population remains cash-dependent. The SBV study identified distinct consumer segments within South Africa, including “Cash Reliant” users who use cash out of necessity and others, like “Digital Adopters” and “Digital Migrators,” who are open to digital options but still rely on cash for certain transactions.
Interestingly, the study showed that factors like age or income level are not the primary predictors of cash preference. Instead, context and trust play more significant roles. Consumers are more likely to use cash in categories like transportation, food, and utilities, which represent essential and immediate needs. For many, cash serves as a safeguard, particularly in areas where digital payment acceptance is inconsistent or unavailable.
Cash’s Role in Financial Inclusion and Stability
One of cash’s often-overlooked benefits is its role in financial inclusion. Cash is accessible to everyone, regardless of income or access to banking infrastructure. During the COVID-19 pandemic, demand for cash surged globally, as people saw it as a stable, familiar means of managing their finances in uncertain times. In developing economies, cash offers a level of financial stability, allowing people to control spending directly and access funds without navigating complex financial systems.
The persistence of cash also raises important questions for policymakers and financial institutions seeking to drive digital adoption. Forcing a shift away from cash risks alienating vulnerable segments, who may lack the resources or trust to fully transition to digital. Instead, experts suggest a more balanced approach that respects the role of cash while gradually increasing access to digital tools and infrastructure.
Cash as a Safety Net in Africa’s Financial Landscape
Africa’s cash-dominant economy reflects broader social and economic realities, where financial inclusion depends on simplicity, familiarity, and resilience. While digital financial services offer convenience and efficiency, they aren’t yet the perfect fit for all segments of the population. Research indicates that many consumers prefer cash as a “safety net” and are not ready to make a full transition to cashless transactions.
Countries like Kenya and South Africa have seen notable successes with mobile money, but cash remains a critical lifeline for people in areas without consistent digital access or for those who prioritize tangible control over their funds. According to a study by Yale’s School of Management, low-income consumers value the ability to use cash and may be willing to pay premiums for the option to continue using it. Cash, in this context, is less about convenience and more about autonomy and security.
Future Prospects: A Hybrid Approach to Financial Inclusion
Given the complex role of cash in Africa’s economy, a hybrid cash-digital model may offer the best path forward. While digital financial services will continue to grow, an all-digital approach could lead to financial exclusion for vulnerable communities. Instead, a balanced model that integrates cash and digital solutions offers flexibility and adaptability.
The future of financial inclusion in Africa doesn’t lie in eliminating cash but in creating systems that accommodate both cash and digital preferences. In time, as digital infrastructure expands and trust in electronic payments grows, more people may choose to transition. Until then, cash will likely remain a fixture in the African economy, supporting those who rely on it while coexisting with the rise of digital alternatives.
References:
SBV. Consumer Cash Survey White Paper
Genesis Analytics & MasterCard. The True Cost of Cash in South Africa Article
SBV Services. Understanding Consumer Cash Usage in South Africa Report
Yale School of Management. When Cash Isn’t an Option, Consumers Lose Out Article
Stitch. Consumer Preferences for Cash in South Africa Article
Comments